Overall, I do enjoy NetGalley as a service but there are just a few things that bother me about it.
#1 Sequels
I think NetGalley should have a more obvious marker for books that are part of a series. When a publisher doesn’t mark that it’s book #2 or #3, or mention that it’s a sequel, it makes it a little hard to review on time.
#2 Location Locking
It’s the modern age. You know where I am. Why bother showing me things I can’t request?
#3 Timely Approvals
I think there should be a time period before the archive date when reviewers can A: no longer request and B: automatically be declined if they haven’t been already. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been a approved for a title the day before it archives. Which means I have to read the book quickly (along with everything else I have to read) and get the review up or let my feedback rating fall.
#4 Wishes
Are dumb. Either the book is available for request or it isn’t. The end. Don’t make us wish that you uploaded a damn file.
#5 No Choice of Format
I love graphic novels. I hate Adobe Editions. As does my computer. It runs slow on each device I have it on and takes too long to load pages. Do you know how hard it is to read anything when you have to slowly watch each page load? My kindle supports graphic novels, Nooks, to my knowledge, support graphic novels. I would prefer having a choice of format so I can choose to read it on my kindle in black and white or deal with the slow loading in Adobe.
#6 No Mobile App
I don’t want to read the books on my phone, I can do that in the kindle app. But I would prefer a NetGalley mobile app that I can request through and get notifications from. Yes, we receive emails when we’ve been approved or denied but they get lost in a sea of emails. It would be nice to have reminders as well for when a book is about to archive and I have not added my review to NetGalley.
Awesome post! I agree with many of these. I’ll also add, I’d like the ability to unrequest. There are a few that have been pending for so long that I no longer want them!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes!!! Absolutely!
LikeLiked by 1 person
About the archive thing… how about you simply download the book before the archive date and then just read it whenever you find the time? You can still review a book after it’s archive date (as long as you’ve downloaded it before that), I do it all the time 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah but it counts against your feedback rating because it isn’t timely 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
Really? I didn’t know that 😧
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah… Which is why it’s such a peeve when that happens. If I forget to add a review – that’s on me. But when I get a late approval – that’s not fair that I get punished. Especially since I request MONTHS in advance. I’m always looking out 3-4 months so that I have time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think one that would make my list is that you can’t remove/delete your request. Only for the reason that I have a ton of books in “pending” that were released forever ago and I’m clearly not going to get. I find it really annoying to see them sitting there (forever probably) and that I can’t just remove them! Or at least just have them auto-decline them after a cutoff date.
And I also completely agree with the sequels thing. I mean, I guess it’s not too hard to look it up on Goodreads (which I usually do just to be safe) but I know edelweiss shows the sequels and other works. It’s not hard for them to just add that somewhere on here like “Oh hey, this is Book 3 in the series btw”
LikeLike
Totally agreed on a lot of these. I got so excited to see a book I’ve been fangirling so hard over for months on there the other day, rushed to go request it, only to find it’s for people in the UK only with no U. S. one in site. Why bother showing up then? XD And wishes always crack me up. Wonderful post! ❤
LikeLiked by 1 person
There’s a book I requested almost a year ago now that hasn’t been accepted or declined and I asked for it in the prime window when they should be checking for requests. The publishers literally just have to press an accept or decline button.
I got approved for a book, was 30% through when I realized it was the third in a series 🙄 I lived the series but if I hadn’t I would have been so mad.
My tbr would be infinite I’d they had an app. Which is why I need it 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Right? And as for the publisher side, they get thousands of requests, I went through them at my internship it’s a never ending feat. Which is why I think they should have a window to stop reviews or deny or accept all remaining. At the very least if the book archived and we weren’t approved or declined it shouldn’t count toward our rating
LikeLike
I went through them at my internship and it was maybe a couple hundred, but I don’t think it does, it’s just really annoying to have them in limbo 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great post, I love NetGalley but it has caused some headaches I can tell you. I hate it when you don’t hear back about requests, then they all appear at once and its a race to get your ratings back up!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Seriously! I try not to have more than 4 open requests anymore just because of that. It’s so annoying.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The 5th one is damn true…These formats always torture me why can’t I have the same pdf for all books.
LikeLike